See all schools in Carrara QLD 4211
Emmanuel College, Carrara
Combined · Independent · Carrara
"I wish I knew about this website when I was about to choose School"
Lisa, parent
"Finally, one can access the opinions of other students completely transparently."
Fredrik, student
Get access to exclusive content, available only on SchoolParrot!
1 month
A$2.99
First month. Then A$4.99 / month
1 year
A$19
Best valueFirst year. Then A$39 / year.
For Schools and school staff
Do you work as a principal or school staff? Take control of your SchoolParrot profile. Click here
Don’t recommend
Emmanuel is getting worse and worse, especially in the high school
Anywhere but here
Corrupt faculty, terrible experience
Great School
Really enjoyed the inclusiveness of the students and teachers. Everyone wants you to feel welcome
The Ignite Program - The worst decision Emmanuel College ever made.
As a current senior school student at Emmanuel College, I definitely have a few complaints, but one standing out to me is the Ignite program.
For context, recently Emmanuel College started a new program started called 'Ignite'. The ignite program basically takes the top 10% high achievers in each grade and awards them at assemblies.
As a proud non-ignite member, but still high achiever, I can say, so many elements of this program feels bias and insulting.
Sitting through the Ignite assemblies feels like living a nightmare. It basically feels like they are saying "look how much better these people are then you".
But the ultimate worst part of this whole thing, is that the ignite students get opportunities other students don't.
I value my education so highly and I would like to be set up for a future of success. So if an opportunity arose for me to go to a university and "collaboratively develop transformative ideas" I would totally sign up! But my main issue is they don't allow everyone to get the opportunity, only a select group of students.
It is so discriminatory.
It is absolutely disgusting how some students can work so hard, have so much passion and so much potential, yet repeatedly do not get the same opportunities and probably aren't valued the same the ignite students.
If you want your child to be treated and valued equally, do not go to Emmanuel College. I'm not even joking, after the first ignite assembly, a girl had a mental break-down in front of me because she was so genuinely upset that she didn't get in the program, because she and her parents expected more from her.
The ignite program is so disgusting and discriminatory and I wish no other schools ever partake in such a cruel program.
For context, recently Emmanuel College started a new program started called 'Ignite'. The ignite program basically takes the top 10% high achievers in each grade and awards them at assemblies.
As a proud non-ignite member, but still high achiever, I can say, so many elements of this program feels bias and insulting.
Sitting through the Ignite assemblies feels like living a nightmare. It basically feels like they are saying "look how much better these people are then you".
But the ultimate worst part of this whole thing, is that the ignite students get opportunities other students don't.
I value my education so highly and I would like to be set up for a future of success. So if an opportunity arose for me to go to a university and "collaboratively develop transformative ideas" I would totally sign up! But my main issue is they don't allow everyone to get the opportunity, only a select group of students.
It is so discriminatory.
It is absolutely disgusting how some students can work so hard, have so much passion and so much potential, yet repeatedly do not get the same opportunities and probably aren't valued the same the ignite students.
If you want your child to be treated and valued equally, do not go to Emmanuel College. I'm not even joking, after the first ignite assembly, a girl had a mental break-down in front of me because she was so genuinely upset that she didn't get in the program, because she and her parents expected more from her.
The ignite program is so disgusting and discriminatory and I wish no other schools ever partake in such a cruel program.
Emmanuel isn’t what it used to be
Hi,
So I’ve been at Emmanuel for 11 years now and it’s been a rollarcoster to say the least.
Emmanuel is a Christian school based around the Christian belief, but sadly the school has fallen very far away from it with it’s decisions.
Things have started to get a little better when the school introduced the new principle last year.
Then they decided to change the logo. Ok yes the new logo is more modern but at the same time it is going to cost a fortune. And it is going to cost every single parent a fortune to replace the uniforms. Every single door and window has this logo on it and was freshly done in 2020. They are going to spend thousands upon thousand of dollars with this new logo with money that should be going towards the students education and hiring good teachers.
Another fact is that Emmanuel is very behind looking at other schools. It isn’t adapting like other schools. It doesn’t offer better classes. It isn’t teaching students the necessary skills for a future which is different to one 20 years ago.
The class structure needs to change. The lessons are 80% teacher guided and that doesn’t work if you look at the time we are going into now. Look at Hillcrest where the school is only 20% teacher guided and they have no behaviour problems because of it and every student is excelling.
The school even has multiple students leave each year to study classes that Emmanuel just doesn’t provide.
Furthermore Emmanuel College is just not the school you hear about anymore.
So I’ve been at Emmanuel for 11 years now and it’s been a rollarcoster to say the least.
Emmanuel is a Christian school based around the Christian belief, but sadly the school has fallen very far away from it with it’s decisions.
Things have started to get a little better when the school introduced the new principle last year.
Then they decided to change the logo. Ok yes the new logo is more modern but at the same time it is going to cost a fortune. And it is going to cost every single parent a fortune to replace the uniforms. Every single door and window has this logo on it and was freshly done in 2020. They are going to spend thousands upon thousand of dollars with this new logo with money that should be going towards the students education and hiring good teachers.
Another fact is that Emmanuel is very behind looking at other schools. It isn’t adapting like other schools. It doesn’t offer better classes. It isn’t teaching students the necessary skills for a future which is different to one 20 years ago.
The class structure needs to change. The lessons are 80% teacher guided and that doesn’t work if you look at the time we are going into now. Look at Hillcrest where the school is only 20% teacher guided and they have no behaviour problems because of it and every student is excelling.
The school even has multiple students leave each year to study classes that Emmanuel just doesn’t provide.
Furthermore Emmanuel College is just not the school you hear about anymore.
Birmingham Road, 4211, Carrara
Patrick Innes-Hill
07 5561 4000
About SchoolParrot
- SchoolParrot is a review site for schools. We are a company that believes in more transparency within schools. Our platform is open to all users.
Read about SchoolParrot and our company - Reviews are published in real-time without moderation and we want to encourage our users to provide constructive feedback and keep a serious tone. The responsibility lies with the user.
Read our review guidelines